Ok, got into this over the weekend and I may not need to make a gasket. It seems the bolts on the bottom, where the leak was occurring, were less than 10 ft-lbs tight. I snugged them all up to about 25 ft-lbs since I couldn't find a specification on how tight they need to be. Hopefully this is the easy fix to my temporary problem. I got to 25 ft-lbs by going up 5 ft-lbs each pass to 25.