Depends what type of light sending device it is, a photodiode or phototransistor. The photodiode uses light to create an electrical current in the device - don't believe the 'smoked' plastic in the one used would be conducive to this type of device. The phototransistor uses light to provide bias to a transistor to allow current flow through the device from a supplied known voltage/current. Believe this is the device used in our light sensors, since it has 5 volts on it normally.
If standard transistor, the base is the light sensitive part of the transistor, with 5 volts applied to the collector in low light the emitter should have almost no voltage. In a light source there should be voltage (3.5 volts or more?) at the emitter. Be careful checking, since these devices work on very low current - typically 100 to 300 milliamps.